DescriptionThe miniskirt is a tube of fabric that sits on the hips of the wearer and hits at mid-thigh. It is made of stretch denim; the fabric is 99% cotton and 1% spandex, with the spandex giving the denim just enough stretch to be comfortable and conform to the wearer’s shape. The skirt is dark blue with distressed fading on thighs and whiskering (horizontal bands of faded fabric where the fabric has wrinkled over time) at the lower hips. The skirt does not look worn, so the distressing was most likely factory-made to produce an already worn-in look. The skirt has tan contrast stitching, with seams down the front and back and a back yoke. The stitching is noticeable, giving the skirt a casual look, but it is not overly bold. The skirt is a bit rough to the touch and has slightly raised vertical ridges.
The skirt has a wide hem and waistband, and the waistband is interrupted by six belt loops – one on each hip in the front, one on each side slightly towards the back of the skirt, and two in the back center of the waistband. It has five pockets: two rounded front pockets, a small slit change pocket on right side, and two back pockets. The back pockets give the skirt a more unique look, with pointed bottoms and flaps that snap closed. The front pockets are held together with dark bronze grommets at the corners. The skirt features a short zippered fly with a bronze YKK brand zipper. The waistband fastens with a faded bronze button on the outside and a clear plastic button on the inside.
The skirt contains writing in several places. The brand name, “American Eagle,” is embroidered on the back inner waistband in tan cursive. The front waistband button and back pocket snaps each feature the words “AE since 1977” in the same cursive style. The skirt also features two tags, hidden from view on the inside of the skirt. A small tag is attached to the back inner waistband and contains the skirt’s size. Another slightly larger tag is attached to the inner front waistband above the left pocket and contains washing instructions in both French and English.
The skirt is machine washable and can be put in the dryer on a low setting. It was made in China. The even stitching and uniform features show that it was mass-produced; however, there are several loose stitches and the garment does not seem to be of terribly high quality. The tags have faded to a grey-blue and the ink has run slightly, showing that the skirt has been washed at least a few times. The inside of the skirt is a grayish-tan color and has an unfinished quality. The overall styling of the skirt is simple, and the round buttons, cursive writing, and the hip-hugging fabric and cut of the skirt give it a curvy aesthetic.
Central Questions1) How does the miniskirt express identity? (Age, Gender, Ethnicity, Religion, Personal Values, Taste/Aesthetic) What messages does it send, intentionally and unintentionally?
2) Can the miniskirt be generalized? Do they all function in basically the same way, or do different fabrics and styles fundamentally change the message of the skirt?
3) Does wearing a miniskirt keep women from being taken seriously? (Especially in the professional world, but also in cases like the Southwest Airlines incident).
4) Are mini-skirts a tool of feminism (women having the power to express their sexuality), or are they a tool of patriarchy (men gazing at women). How does each group view and use the miniskirt?
5) What effects does wearing a mini-skirt have on the wearer and on those around her?
ArgumentThe miniskirt was originally worn in the 1960s as an expression of feminism and uninhibited sexuality. Third-wave feminists of the late 1990s and early 2000s see the miniskirt in a similar way. However, the culture at large disagrees, and wearing a miniskirt sends a message that is the antithesis of feministic. On the surface, it invites the sexual attention of men, turning the wearer into nothing more than an aesthetic object. However, more damagingly, the miniskirt sends a message that the wearer is young and not serious enough for “the real world.” This is especially problematic in a business setting: while men might appreciate a young colleague’s sexy work outfits, they may cost her the benefit of being taken seriously in the workplace and damage her ability to rise in the ranks of the corporate world.
Annotated BibliographyCostello, Carrie Yang. “Changing Clothes: Gender Inequality and Professional Socialization.” NWSA Journal, 16.2 (Summer 2004): 138-155.
This article discusses how clothing demonstrates identity in a professional setting. It discusses a young law student named Lydia who begins her training wearing short skirts but switches to a more androgynous look. It is especially interesting because it compares Lydia to the character of Ally McBeal, a TV lawyer who was famous for wearing very short miniskirts and sexing up professional dress in the late 1990s.Frankel, Susannah. “Get shorty: the mini’s back.” The Independent. 31 January, 2001.
This article provides an interesting look at the miniskirt at the turn of the 21st century. Frankel touches on both the history and debate surrounding the miniskirt in her article, as well as looking at some current trends.Hammers, Michele L. “Cautionary Tales of Liberation and Female Professionalsm: The Case Against Ally McBeal.” Western Journal of Communication. 69.2 (April 2005): 167-182.
This article uses the TV show Ally McBeal as a case study to examine how female identity in the working world has been played out in recent years. It discusses feminism and portrayal of the female body in the professional world, concluding that women such as Ally McBeal are not, in fact, in control of their sexuality, but are, on the contrary, playing into the patriarchal system. “Miniskirt.” Icons: A Portrait of England. 27 February 2008.
http://www.icons.org.uk/theicons/collection/miniskirtThis website provides a comprehensive history and analysis of the miniskirt. Articles cover topics such as the miniskirt and women’s lib and the creator of the miniskirt, Mary Quant. The site also features lots of images.
Nicks, Joan. “Hemlines.” St. James Encyclopedia for Pop Culture. Gale Group, 2002.
This article gives a brief history of skirt lengths. It discusses how skirts have been represented in popular culture since the 1950s, such as Lucy of “I Love Lucy” and Harriet of “The Adventures of Ozzy and Harriet.” It culminates with a discussion about the late 1990s TV character Ally McBeal.Schoetz, David. “Underdressed Passenger or Overreacting Airline?” ABCNews.com. September, 2007.
http://abcnews.go.com/US/Travel/story?id=3571435&page=1This news article from ABC News discusses the case of Kyla Ebbert, the young woman who was recently kicked off of a Southwest Airlines flight for wearing a skirt that was deemed too short. It shows how the miniskirt is still a controversial fashion item in our society.
Wilson, Elizabeth. Adorned in Dreams: Fashion and Modernity. Rutgers University Press: New Brunswick, New Jersey, 2003.
This book explores the function of fashion in the modern era, rejecting older theories and explaining that modern society uses clothing to express different messages than it did previously. Chapters explore topics such as fashion and eroticism, gender and identity, and fashion and popular culture. Although the miniskirt is only explicitly mentioned a few times, the arguments made by the authors about the aesthetics and meaning of modern fashion are certainly applicable to the miniskirt.
Assorted clothing websites:
AeropostaleAmerican EagleCharlotte RusseKohl’sNordstromOld Navy
These are some examples of the skirts that are currently for sale at several American retail chains. Looking at the current trends shows the miniskirt’s popularity right now as well as who is wearing it and how it is being marketed.